Safety First Episode 4
In this episode, Amanda talks to Dr. Jennifer Middleton about two distinct topics related to adolescent health: nicotine pouches and diet and nutrition. They discuss the effects of nicotine on the adolescent brain, the availability of nicotine pouches, the effects of consuming ultraprocessed foods and the benefits of whole foods among teens.
Resources from the Episode
*The views and opinions expressed in this episode are those of the guest alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the host, the Safety First team or any affiliated organizations.
Transcript of Safety First Episode 4
Amanda Giordano: You're listening to "Safety First: Tackling Tough Topics with Teens." Our goal is to provide useful information about issues that affect today's teenagers. To help support parents and professionals who work with youth.
Hello, everyone, and thank you for joining us today on the "Safety First" podcast. I'm excited to introduce our guest today, Jennifer Middleton. Jennifer is an associate program director with the OhioHealth Riverside Family Medicine Residency Program, OhioHealth Title XI coordinator and educational specialist with OhioHealth Provider Well-Being.
She completed her residency training at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center St. Margaret Family Medicine Residency Program in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, followed by the University of Pittsburgh's two-year, full-time Faculty Development Fellowship, along with a master's degree in public health from the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health.
She has published original research and essays in multiple peer-reviewed journals and has presented nationally on a wide variety of faculty development and medical education topics. In fall of 2024, she began her master's of divinity degree work at Trinity Lutheran Seminary at Capital University in Bexley, Ohio. And after graduation, she hopes to merge medicine and spirituality into a harmonious calling.
Welcome, Jennifer, and thank you so much for being here today.
Dr. Jennifer Middleton: It's my pleasure. Thank you so much for the invitation.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. So I really want to dive right in, but I wanted to give you the opportunity to tell us a little bit about your work and your professional journey that got you to where you are today.
Jennifer Middleton: Sure. Absolutely. So I am a family physician that has definitely been my primary professional identity through all the things that I have done so far in my career. I have a passion for medical education and for supporting our learners with evidence-based teaching techniques and strategies and have spent much of my career doing that.
I recently transitioned into the Provider Well-being Department at OhioHealth, and I'm really enjoying getting the chance to holistically support residents who are not making the progress they would like in residency and are looking for ways to improve what they do.
I have also done quite a bit of writing throughout my career. I stepped away from my editorial role when I started school in 2024, as you mentioned, but I enjoy writing and editing and appreciate the opportunity to just kind of think critically and stay on top of all of the new things that are constantly coming at us in the field of medicine.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. Gosh, you have such a great wealth of experiences and knowledge to share. So we're really excited to hear from you. What's your opinion about some of the biggest threats to adolescent health today?
Jennifer Middleton: Absolutely. I think it is a challenging time to be an adolescent. Not that adolescence is an easy time at any point in history, but right now, I think, you know, we are still grappling a lot with the implications of this digitally native generation. Of learning how to filter through the information that comes at them at lightning speed in a way that previous generations did not have to. And at the ever increasing savvy of marketers who are hawking products at them and potentially not always with their best interests in mind.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. And so are there a couple of specific things that you've seen in your work or you're aware of that are causing harm to the physical health and the wellness of adolescents today?
Jennifer Middleton: Absolutely. Well, we, you know, really celebrated one of the great public health wins of the 20th century in terms of decreasing the rate of smoking cigarette use in this population.
Unfortunately, nicotine marketers have figured out how to target this generation and have found a way to package nicotine now in these little pouches that do not have tobacco in them and are being heavily marketed to teenagers.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. And so I'm excited for parents who are listening and professionals who work with youth who are listening to understand these nicotine pouches a little bit more. So what do we know about them? What are the risks that they pose to adolescents?
Jennifer Middleton: Well, I would say one of the biggest risks they pose to adolescents is the presence of the nicotine itself. So we know from decades of study of the effects of nicotine in tobacco, that nicotine impacts and affects developing brains. And the human brain is not really done doing all of its developing until about age 24 to 25. So impacting those neural patterns with these potentially addictive substances such as nicotine, I would put marijuana in that list as well, can create some lifelong challenges for folks.
And the people who are marketing these products know that. They know that if they get someone addicted to nicotine during these formative years, they're more likely to have a customer for life.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah, and I think that you're helping to dispel some of the myths that the issue is really with the combustible tobacco products rather than with the nicotine itself. So what is the draw for teens to nicotine pouches?
Jennifer Middleton: Well, teens are very savvy in this day and age, and they are well aware of the risks of tobacco products, including cigarettes and chew, which are not very popular in that age group. They understand the risks of cancer that come from those combustible products. And everybody likes to get a little boost of energy and that little dopamine hit from time to time. Nicotine is very capable of doing that in its pure or chemical form, separated out from those combustible, carcinogenic materials.
So it is marketed in a very kid-friendly way. If you Google nicotine pouches and look at a lot of the advertising and images, they almost look like candy containers in a way. They are small. They're easy to, you know, be discreet with in class or at home. And again, there's this perception of safety because we've removed the tobacco piece.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. So really, it's the nicotine that can interrupt adolescent brain development. But then also, it's a very addictive substance that's creating this lifelong customer.
Jennifer Middleton: Absolutely. And, you know, the challenge with nicotine, you know, we don't have enough science yet to know what the long-term risks of only nicotine absent the tobacco is. But any substance that is creating that neural groove of addiction and of reuse, that hit of, you know, getting the pleasure of using the substance and then wanting to use it again. Sounds worrisome to me.
Amanda Giordano: Sure. Yeah. So really engaging that reward circuitry. And I like how you mentioned that, whether it's nicotine, whether it's cannabis products, we're seeing a lot of the same behaviors there with youth.
Jennifer Middleton: Yes, absolutely. And the concern always is once you kind of start activating that reward pathway, as you said, what we worry about, I don't have substantiated science to say this for the record, but what the worry is, once you have experienced that, are you at risk potentially of looking for other ways that are potentially even more unsafe?
Amanda Giordano: Well, that's fascinating. And I want to shift gears a little bit. Just knowing your background and all of this information that you have to share with us, I'd love to talk a little bit about adolescents' diet and nutrition. So kind of still under that umbrella of adolescent health. But shifting from the nicotine pouches, what would you want parents to know about ensuring that their children and their teens are getting a healthy diet?
Jennifer Middleton: Yeah, absolutely. I think the first piece to be aware of as a parent, which again is different than the experiences of most of us growing up, is this just unrelenting pressure about how bodies are supposed to look and about this idea of achieving this perfect interior health, this inner health also in the body. And that is driven very heavily by social media. I'm not here to say that social media is all bad. It's a tool. It can be used well. It can be used not well.
And we know that the amount of exposure that teens are getting to these kind of perfect lifestyle and these perfect body appearance can affect how they think about nutrition. So I would really encourage parents, number one, be aware of how much time your kids are spending and be curious. Ask them what they're looking at, what influencers are they following so that you can have a sense about are these healthy messages or are there some messages here that I want to counteract?
At the end of the day, you know, the most important thing for nutrition for all people, regardless of age, is as much as is possible. And I don't want to let my public health background get in here too much because depending on your zip code, you may have greater or decreased access to these things, is a diet that is primarily whole foods and plant based. That doesn't mean all plants, but if most of the food you're eating comes from the perimeter of the grocery store, it's being prepared at home as opposed to ultra processed, overprocessed foods. We have quite a bit of scientific research telling us this is the diet for optimum health.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah, and I think we hear that a lot, right, that this ultraprocessed food is not great, and if you have the resources and the means to get the whole foods. But what is the risk associated with the ultraprocessed foods? How does that impact an adolescent?
Jennifer Middleton: Well, it can impact things in a couple of ways. Number one, ultraprocessed foods tend to be what is known as hyper palatable, meaning they are delicious. And the folks who make them know how to make them more delicious than what would be available otherwise. So if you consume a lot of these foods in childhood and adolescence, your taste buds, your palate for what is healthy, delicious food is going to be skewed toward these more ultraprocessed foods. You're going to be setting up kind of for a lifetime of expecting this is what food is supposed to taste like. If your exposure is more toward that.
Again, whole foods can be delicious, but they can't compete with a lot of the chemical and other additives that processors put in to drive folks to want to buy in these foods. Right. You never hear about anybody eating an entire bag of broccoli and they can't stop themselves. Even though I would argue broccoli is delicious. But chips or candy or other sort of things, it's very easy to keep going past the point of recognizing that you're full because they're hyper palatable. Because they are abnormally or atypically delicious in some way.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. So changing the expectation of what delicious food should be and almost it's like those natural foods or whole foods are dwarfed by these ultraprocessed. They just, like you said, can't compete. So that becomes the preference. And what would happen if a teen's diet is now 100% ultraprocessed? What are some of the drawbacks of that type of diet?
Jennifer Middleton: Well, the biggest risk is that you are likely not to be benefiting from the full nutrition array that you are able to get from whole foods. Because, yes, you can pump artificial vitamins and other things into those ultraprocessed foods, but you're missing out on a lot of the benefits that come that we're still just learning how to study. The antioxidant properties, for example, in a lot of fruits and vegetables.
Fruits which are naturally sweet, come packaged with nature's antidote to sugar, which is fiber. And most folks eating an ultraprocessed diet are not getting enough fiber, which causes a lot of problems for gut health both now and down the line.
We have increasing science coming out about the importance of the microbiome. What are the different bacteria that live in the gut? Ultraprocessed foods change that microbiome, and that appears to have longstanding effects potentially on the immune system and even on cancer risk.
Amanda Giordano: Wow. Yeah. So lots of changes there that are happening internally, that are happening even in the brain about the expectations for food from having this ultraprocessed diet. So what suggestions or advice would you give to parents then, knowing that ultra processed foods are available, they are often very affordable and it might be what their kids' friends are consuming as well?
Jennifer Middleton: Oh absolutely. And as a parent myself, I will tell you it is completely unrealistic to try to restrict or abolish all interaction with these kinds of foods. It's not realistic.
And you don't want to set up the idea with your kids, with your teens, that there are bad foods and good foods. There are foods that in general to be healthy we should have more of. And there are foods that sometimes we eat because we enjoy them and we are social human beings and that is okay.
So it's talking about this idea of balance. And I think what's the environment that we do have control over is the environment in our homes. So where most of the time can we be offering, you know, our families things that are more whole food and more plant based.
And I get it. Listen, I'm a family doctor. Do my kids eat every single meal, whole foods plant based? No, they do not, because life is busy and challenging and sometimes you do the best you can with what you've got. So this is not about perfection. It's about doing the best you can within the resources in the time that you have to have those options available for your family. And to talk about things are really busy today so this is what we're going to be eating. But I'm so glad tomorrow will have more time for a home-cooked meal. Talking about those values and what you see as being important in those foods can be really powerful role modeling for kids also.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. So I'm just curious, what are some of the staples that you have in your home, those options you like to have for your kids?
Jennifer Middleton: So we work really hard to always have some fresh fruits and vegetables lying around for our kiddos and if they are hungry before dinner, that is the option.
One of my daughters is a yogurt fiend and so we work really hard to have low sugar or, you know, high-fat yogurts which are associated with better satiety. So fat is not bad necessarily in dairy and other foods. If you take the fat out, then you are tempted to put more sugar in. And that's not what we're trying to do. So we have a lot of lower sugar options regarding yogurts available in our house for kids.
And do we have, you know, some potato chips and granola bars? We do, but we try to choose things that are less processed. I’ve become a bit of an ingredient reading hawk. So I don't like things that have artificial colors or have high-fructose corn syrup. Again, these are things that kind of make foods look and taste hyper palatable. But things that are made with more natural ingredients when possible.
Amanda Giordano: Do you have any suggestions or advice to parents about what teens drink? I think that's something that you hear quite a bit, that now we've got energy drinks and we've got sodas and the zero sugar and so what are some suggestions you might have for nutritious or balanced beverages?
Jennifer Middleton: Absolutely. Well, you can never go wrong with water, my friends. You can never go wrong with water.
You know, in general, drinking sugar is a fast track to disease and to not being well later in life. So minimizing drinking sugar, that includes juices. Juices, again, have that fiber stripped out of them that nature packages with the fruit to minimize the effect of the sugar in the fruit. So minimizing fruit juices, minimizing soft drinks.
Is zero sugar soft drink better than a full sugar soft drink? It is. And we don't have great safety data long term on a lot of those artificial sweeteners. So I think it's important to limit those also.
Amanda Giordano: So kind of in closing here, you've given so much good information for parents about the nicotine pouches and about nutrition. What if a parent is looking for some help with their child? What are some resources that are out there for parents?
Jennifer Middleton: Well, absolutely. First and foremost, check in with your family doctor or your child's pediatrician. We as a profession in medicine who take care of this age group, work really hard to stay up to date. When I was working as, you know, the journal editor, one of my jobs was to provide that information to folks caring for this age population. So reach out to them. They have resources that are available to help you.
You can also find websites such as AAFP is the American Academy of Family Physicians and AAP, the American Academy of Pediatricians. Both have excellent websites with patient information.
Amanda Giordano: Great, fantastic. And I kind of wanted to give you the last word here of just any encouragement or suggestions you have for parents today who are trying to raise healthy teens and are, you know, up against all of these obstacles, what might you say to those listeners?
Jennifer Middleton: I would say be gentle with yourself. It is tough. There are a lot of external pressures on us as parents, on our kids, and on our teens. We do the best we can with what we have and we give ourselves grace for the rest.
So be informed, but also give yourself permission to not be perfect and role model that for your kids, you know, so that they can learn how to make the best decisions they can later in life.
Amanda Giordano: Fantastic. Jennifer, thank you so much for being here today and sharing all of this information.
And listeners, thank you so much for joining us on another "Safety First" podcast where we tackle tough topics affecting today's teens. I'm your host, Amanda Giordano, and we hope you'll join us for our next episode.