Safety First Episode 6
In this episode, Amanda Giordano talks with Jean Rogers about digital media use among adolescents. They discuss the impact of digital media use on teens, risks such as cyberbullying, advocacy efforts, and both helpful and unhelpful strategies for managing teens' digital media use.
Resources from the Episode
*The views and opinions expressed in this episode are those of the guest alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the host, the Safety First team or any affiliated organizations.
Transcript of Safety First Episode 6
Amanda Giordano: You're listening to "Safety First: Tackling Tough Topics with Teens." Our goal is to provide useful information about issues that affect today's teenagers. To help support parents and professionals who work with youth.
Hi, everyone, and thank you so much for joining us today on the "Safety First" podcast. I'm so excited to introduce our guest, Jean Rogers. Jean is director of Fairplay Screen Time Action Network, an expert in movement building and establishing key partnerships that support child well-being in a digital world. Jean is also a certified parent, educator and coauthor of the new book “Screen-Aware Early Childhood,” just released by Teachers College Press.
She works to encourage and support activists and believes sound child development is the key to a peaceful, productive future. Jean, welcome. And thank you so much for being here today.
Jean Rogers: Thanks so much, Amanda. I'm glad to be with you.
Amanda Giordano: Well, just to get us started, tell us a little bit about your work and your professional journey.
Jean Rogers: Thanks so much. I started my career and my early career was as a writer, and I did some journalism, some speechwriting. And then I landed in a more lucrative industry in the marketing and writing industry.
And when I had my daughter and my twin boys, I realized I don't want to be using my talents to convince people they need things they don’t need.
Amanda Giordano: Okay.
Jean Rogers: You know, the marketing writing, and I started realizing how media was impacting my own children at the time. And then we were really only dealing with video games, TV and a little bit of those portable DS devices. But then I wrote a book called “Kids Under Fire,” which was for parents to empower children to make healthy choices around media because they're not always going to be there to help them and have a funny story.
My kids, I was on vacation at the Red Jacket Inn in northern New Hampshire. I live in southern New Hampshire. And they were having one of those nights where people could go out to dinner, parents could go out to dinner and leave the kids for the activities. Well, we had screen rules in our house, and they were playing a "Rugrats" movie. And my daughter took her little twin brothers and marched up to them and the people in charge and said, “We're not allowed to watch 'Rugrats.'”
And you know, I know people love Rugrats, but they tend to talk back to your parents, to be rude to your siblings or, you know, things that, you know, we have to worry about so much more now.
But they said to me, “Your daughter is going to be a leader someday.” You know, they changed the video to "Mary Poppins" for her. And the kids were just like, they were just like 5 and 7. So I think, really early on, I realized that you have to be involved with your kids. You have to make decisions every day about their media when you’re parents.
And so I went back to school, got a master's in education and parenting education, and then landed here at Fairplay, where I've been since 2016. Really grateful to be able to do this work with so many advocates, so many great professionals.
Amanda Giordano: Well, I want to dive right in because I know this is a topic that's so important to so many people. Digital media use is ubiquitous today. So in your opinion, how has digital media use impacted today's youth?
Jean Rogers: My goodness, Amanda, so many ways. But I like to start by having us think not really about what digital media has done to them. We'll talk about that a little bit later. But what it's deprived them of.
So even if they've never seen a violent video, never been cyberbullied, never encountered a predator, just from a pure time standpoint and attention standpoint, it has robbed them of life-affirming relationships and experiences to decide what they want to see and learn. You know, those corporations are deciding what they put in front of them, and it's depriving them of that training ground for adulthood, you know, opportunities to make mistakes while they're still at home.
My twin boys, again, when they were older, both had car accidents when they first got their driver's licenses, you know, and I was able to support them through that. Kids are not getting their driver's license now. They're getting it later and later because they're having that social interaction only online. They don't need that freedom.
So, and there are a couple of other reasons I just want to mention. I think understanding money and finances, they get this warped sense of money online, the witnessing people making gobs of money being influencers, you know, not by hard labor or being of service in the real world. And, you know, they're not getting part-time jobs, earning money thoughtfully, that kind of thing. Money is kind of like sand or water when you spend it online.
And then agency, you know, really don't video those fights. Go do something about it, go get help. And just learning ethics in a different way online. So many ways. But I like to start with that. Like, what are they not getting because they're spending so many hours online.
Amanda Giordano: So thoughtful. And you really touched on areas that I hadn't thought about before. I mean, thinking about ethics, thinking about agency, freedom in driving. And I think you bring up such a great point that when we think about digital media use, we often think about what are they being exposed to that's harmful? And you're saying let's also consider what are they not experiencing on devices and on digital media? Like what are they missing out on?
Jean Rogers: Yeah. To me, that's a you know, a sad part of that.
Amanda Giordano: Well, tell us a little bit more. What are the potential risks or harms of digital media use among teens?
Jean Rogers: Yeah, sadly, there are so many because of the algorithms and the profit motives. And I really want everyone who's listening to understand that corporate profits are coming before children's well-being. They're insidious. And that's what's happening online right now.
Probably the most commonly known is cyberbullying. And although most of our listeners know what that is, I'm not sure. I just want to take a moment to say it's not like schoolyard bullying and it can completely shred a teen’s sense of self. And there's just no getting away from it. There's no leaving the schoolyard and going home. The bully goes with you all the way to your bedroom, and it now happens 24/7.
And it's really the definition of cyberbullying, receiving unwanted contact, having their passwords stolen and used by bullies to hack into their accounts, means using students likenesses and airdropping it to the whole school. So things that really humiliate, fake news, having rumors spread online and just early exposure to pornography. So something that we never had to worry so much about in the past.
So, I would love you to point people to our online Harms Prevention Action kit that lists all of these harms. Those are just a few that are top of mind for me, but it lists all the harms and shows you ways to deal with it and ways to talk to kids about them.
Amanda Giordano: Great. So what can parents and families do? What are some helpful strategies that families can implement with regard to screen time and digital media use to help support their kids?
Jean Rogers: So we know all parents want what's best for their children. And I just think starting from there is so, so important. It's very easy to look around you at a restaurant or in the mall or at a sporting event and see someone hand their kids an iPad and judge immediately what they're doing. So I think removing judgment is so important.
Talking to your kids about their digital lives. It's not fun. It's not what we really want to do. But attempt to solve problems together is so important. And you can do that at any age from a very young age, you can ask children questions about their online lives, ask what it's making them feel like, what it's, you know, would they rather be doing something else?
Often they say yes. Often they'd rather be outside or they'd rather be playing with their siblings.
So I think having those respectful conversations is really important and it really helps kids to feel a sense of ownership and belonging with those decisions around the family.
I may think, I'm not saying that parents shouldn't be authoritative. They definitely should have rules and ask kids to stick with rules. Kids love boundaries as well. And in the digital world, we really need to set a lot of boundaries for them. But reasoning with them, helping them to understand why you're making those decisions is going to be really critical.
And then creating community around the issue. I think parents need peer support and kids need peer support. None of us wants our kid to be the only one on the field trip bus without the headphones. But if there are 7 of you in a class.
We really love our partner Wait Until 8th, supporting you know, if a class does Wait Until 8th together, then all of the families and all of the kids don't have those cellphones.
Dr. Amanda Giordano: And what is Wait Until 8th for those who might not know?
Jean Rogers: Thank you so much for saying that, I sometimes take that for granted.
Wait Until 8th is a program that happens in schools that any parent can initiate it and that the class signs a pact that they're going to wait until eighth grade before they give their kids a cellphone. So the younger you start that, the better. Like if in third grade, you start with parents who say they're going to wait until eighth, then those kids have all of those years and look at how fast we understood digital technology.
I mean, that's one of the myths that they need to have it early. They can have it when they're 12. They can have it when they're 14, 16, 18, and they'll be fine on it for the rest of their lives. But it will give them back all of that time and all of those experiences that they need to develop into fantastic adults.
I mean, sometimes I worry about the societal cost of all this. These children will be our leaders, and so we want them to have problem solving skills, cooperation skills, creativity and all of that.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah.
Jean Rogers: We need them to solve the big problems.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. Thank you. And along with those great suggestions for what families can do, have you come across any unhelpful strategies or things that might not work?
Jean Rogers: I sure have. So the first thing I always say is don't tell the kids, “Turn that thing off,” or “Put that thing away.” Because now, just like us their whole life is in there and their friends are in there. And you know, if you haven't set those rules ahead, coming in and taking it away like that is really painful for them.
I don't recommend using it as a reward or a punishment. And that's so hard for people to understand. I know that you want them to do their chores and then you can say, “And then you'll get screen time.” But if you can say, “Do your chores and then you'll get time with your friends,” or “Do your chores, and then you'll get an extra dessert,” like whatever you want to say, you'll get to pick the dessert tonight or something. It's going to be more effective because what you take away always seems more appealing to them. They're going to want to sneak it. You know, there's using it for rewards or punishment. I don't recommend. And it sounds like a cliche, but it's really never too late to have conversations, even if you've already had too much screen time in your home.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. And that leads right into my next question, because I imagine people who are listening to this, there are some parents who might already feel defeated when it comes to addressing screen time with their teens, maybe thinking it's too late. So what advice might you have for those parents who think that their teens might already have an unhealthy relationship with digital media?
Jean Rogers: I just wanna, you know, affirm that it's so easy to feel discouraged, especially now we have artificial intelligence and we're dealing with and there's always something new. And it seems like the new technologies are coming out lightning fast and we can't keep up with them.
And we just want to have that simple, peaceful family life. And so, you know, don't feel bad if you do feel discouraged. But like I just said, it's never too late.
I think finding that peer support and community that I mentioned earlier is going to be critical. So that you or your child feels like you are freaking out or this is really getting to be too much that you can go to those friends for you and for your children who are living similar values around their media.
And then here at the Screen Time Action Network at Fairplay, we have so many resources, including a new guide that's coming out from our mental health work group, which Amanda can speak to a little bit. And there are both residential and outpatient treatment programs that we have connections with here at the Action Network as well.
I don't think people really know that that screen addiction is treatable. And, you know, the earlier it's caught, obviously the better. But as I said, it's never too late. And so one of these facilities is in Washington state, one in Boulder, Colorado, and there's online support for it as well.
So I think looking into that kind of support. If it feels serious, if you feel in danger, if you feel as though your child is checking out of life in a very much bigger way than looking into those more serious supports is important.
Amanda Giordano: Right. Thank you. And I want to ask you about your book in just a second. But since you do so much work with advocacy, I'm just curious your opinion about how society could best support adolescents and teens when it comes to screen time and digital media use.
Jean Rogers: So we have a whole policy department here at Fairplay and passing legislation to make big tech companies accountable is critical. They're doing an experiment on our children's lives, and at Fairplay we work to expose those exploitative and harmful business practices of marketers and big tech.
Two big bills that you could focus on supporting are the Kids Online Safety Act, KOSA. It passed the Senate last year, 91 to 3. Nothing passes 91 to 3. So this is a bipartisan issue. All sides want to protect the children. This bill gives corporations a duty of care where children's needs come before profit. And it requires these firms to be more careful. Remove the harmful algorithms and manipulations in the apps and games that are hurting children. But now we need it to pass the House.
And I always think as a parent educator, when I help a parent in their home, it's great. I really appreciate the progress I see. But it's like putting a Band-Aid on the problem because the problem is the corporations are selling you this and they're telling you this is what your children need and they're harming the children in the process. So this is why we want to go to this legislation.
So the first being KOSA, the second being COPPA 2.0, and that's the Children's Online Privacy and Protection Act. The original COPPA was passed in 1998. As you can imagine, we didn't have all this back then. Children were not on the internet in 1998. You know, it was well before the internet, apps and games and before portable digital devices could be taken into bed, could be taken outside, could be taken where.
So we're working to support those two bills and many others. And just realizing the kids are our future and we need them to be able to think and deal with these complex problems, that we need the corporations to get out of childhood, get out of schools.
Amanda Giordano: Your new book, “Screen-Aware Early Childhood” with Pat Cantor and Mindy Holohan was just released on Oct. 24. So what can you tell us about the approach and the tools that this book provides?
Jean Rogers: Well, thanks for asking, Amanda. We wrote this book even though there are many books about screen time out there. And so we thought maybe we're crazy writing another one, but we found that early childhood educators and parents of young children were confused. There are so many resources out there now. Which ones? You know, and some of them have these corporate interests behind them.
And so can we trust those? What resources can we trust?
So we wanted them to know that these problems don't start in the teen years. So we've talked a lot about teens and older children today, but they don't start there. We hear quite a bit about teen mental health, which is really important and good that we're working on that.
But we want to prevent it. We want to get prevention out there. We don't hear as much that those iPads you're handing the kids at the restaurant like we talked about earlier, are also engaging them in long term effects, like getting them used to the digital rewards instead of playing and learning for its own sake. So many don't in managing screen time.
And we wanted this book to be a positive approach. Our framework that we discuss is called Safe Screen-Aware Framework for Early Childhood, and it's strength-based, and, you know, your audience is safety-focused. It's strength-based so that families can see, "What supports do I already have around me?" For instance, if you live close to family, could you use them to babysit instead of having the kids on the devices? That would be a strength that you have. Are there activities that you already love to do as a family?
For instance, you know, can you go on bike rides together, go outdoors, have siblings cheer each other on at sporting events, and instead of one staying home on the devices and going with the others? Maybe your family loves to exercise. Maybe you have a faith community. So we focus on what strengths you already have in place that you can use and make these issues a little bit less scary.
And then we also discuss four prevailing myths about screen use in childhood. The earlier is better myth, the digital native myth, the apps make kids smarter myth and the fact that it's fully the parents' responsibility myth. So those are things that society keeps telling us and we wanted to debunk those with research.
So it's all research-based, and we're really pleased to be able to get it out there.
Amanda Giordano: Jean, thank you so much for taking your time to be with us today.
And I wanted to give you the last word. If you have any encouragement or suggestions for parents today or professionals who work with youth, what might it be?
Jean Rogers: So I really appreciate this opportunity, Amanda, to be with you and your community. This is a complex problem, and it's good for parents to know this information that we're giving them, but it's also important to trust their gut. I think, you know, you're a good parent. You know what's good for your kids. None of this is your fault. It's industry. It's not a fair fight.
So if I could ask parents to just trust themselves and educators as well, trust yourself. You know what's best for the children and learn some of this. Also, just bring your heart to this media issue with children.
Amanda Giordano: Thanks Jean and for everyone joining us and listening thank you so much for being with us on the "Safety First" podcast where we tackle tough topics affecting today's teens. I'm your host, Amanda Giordano, and we hope you'll join us for our next episode.