Safety First Episode 8
In this episode, Amanda Giordano talks with Erin Birely, a licensed clinical professional counselor, about disordered eating among adolescents. They discuss the various types of eating disorders, the role of emotional avoidance and biopsychosocial risk factors.
Resources from the Episode
*The views and opinions expressed in this episode are those of the guest alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the host, the Safety First team or any affiliated organizations.
Transcript of Safety First Episode 8
Amanda Giordano: You're listening to "Safety First: Tackling Tough Topics with Teens." Our goal is to provide useful information about issues that affect today's teenagers. To help support parents and professionals who work with youth.
Hello, everyone, and thank you for joining us today on the "Safety First" podcast. I am very excited to introduce our guest, Erin Birely, who is a licensed clinical professional counselor and the alumni services coordinator at the Renfrew Center. Prior to joining Renfrew in 2016, she worked in private practice as well as inpatient, partial and intensive outpatient levels of care. Birely has worked in the field of eating disorder treatment since receiving her master's degree in 2012. She enjoys working with people to make positive and long-lasting changes in life through therapy and building their emotional tolerance.
Erin, thank you so much for joining us today.
Erin Birely: Thank you so much for having me, Amanda. I'm happy to be here.
Amanda Giordano: Well, why don't we just start with you telling us anything else about your work or your professional journey that wasn’t your bio and how you ended up working with eating disorders?
Erin Birely: Yeah. You know, it's interesting because eating disorders had always been something that just intrigued me. I remember my undergraduate required us to do kind of a research thesis as part of a graduation requirement. I was talking with my advisor. I was like, you know, I was always intrigued by like, what impacted an eating disorder development because it seemed like something that it was like, how do those behaviors become what somebody gets so focused on? And he encouraged me to, you know, do my research on that. And I looked specifically at environment and how that played a role and like different school environments, academic pressure, but then also social pressure, all of those different things.
And after that, when I was in my master's program, I had the opportunity to intern at a eating disorder, higher level of care treatment facility, and I figured I'd give it a shot. I’d see how it goes. And I really loved working with the population because, you know, that initial question of like, “Okay, why these behaviors?” really got answered. Because it was what was available, you know, it was what was there, and it was what felt comfortable to them for whatever reason.
And it's no different than any other way that the rest of us use avoidance behaviors to kind of push away those uncomfortable emotions. It's just that these set of behaviors can cause a lot of problems physically and emotionally.
And so I really just dove into the field and have loved working with the population ever since, because I feel like it's such a human problem and it's one that really requires letting yourself feel your emotions. There is no avoidance that can happen. You know, there's not a well, we just never have to think about this food ever again. It's like, no food is a part of life. You know, your body is a part of life. We're going to have to think about these things. So how do we let go of some of that avoidance?
And when I started with Renfrew and their unified treatment model, it really just lined up perfectly with my own personal philosophy of let's reduce avoidance, let's work on really leaning in and building emotional tolerance. Because if we just replace these behaviors with something else, those can become harmful later also. So let's work on the underlying problem as opposed to just kind of chopping things off that we can see.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. This is a podcast that's really designed for parents, professionals who work with youth. So how would you explain an eating disorder for folks who maybe haven't been trained, gone to school for that particular area? How would you describe it?
Erin Birely: Yeah, so an eating disorder is, you know, characterized by the behaviors that are used. So there are behaviors that are used around food, weight management, body image to help the person avoid feeling uncomfortable emotions. So the behaviors themselves are what make an eating disorder, an eating disorder.
But the underlying theme of emotional avoidance is the same thing you're dealing with, with a client with anxiety or obsessive compulsive disorder or depression, or just a little bit of social anxiety or school refusal, all those different things.
But specifically for somebody with an eating disorder, we are looking at very specific behaviors around control with food, weight, body shape, body size and there are different ways the behaviors can show up. But, underlying, it's around that emotional avoidance.
Amanda Giordano: And when you speak of emotional avoidance. So this is a individual who is struggling with a very powerful emotion that they don't know how to cope with or navigate. And so they turn to this disordered eating behavior, correct?
Erin Birely: Yes. Yeah. And that's a natural experience for all of us. I mean, you think about all of us, we experience emotions and it's like, my gosh, I don't know how to deal with this. I don't know how to handle this.
I always think it's interesting when I’ll talk to parents of adolescent clients, they're like, you know, because it's so dramatic right now. And I'm like, yeah, it is because it's their first time dealing with that emotion and so feels really, really big. You and I, we've dealt with that emotion and bigger ones at this point in our life. But for them it is that big. So it's not that I'm being dramatic, it's that this is their first foray into it. It's like if you're learning how to surf the first time you hit a little wave, you're going to be super excited. But if you're a pro surfer, you're going to be like, “No, it's not that impressive.”
Amanda Giordano: Yeah, that's a very empathetic stance, too, on what adolescents are going through. So tell us, what are some of the forms of disordered eating that you see among adolescents?
Erin Birely: So anorexia nervosa has to do with restricting intake and a fear of weight gain. They can have behaviors around bingeing and purging as a way to control weight. But anorexia is usually a stronger focus on restriction of food intake. Whereas bulimia nervosa has more of the binge purge behaviors taking center stage a little bit where those are the more commonly used behaviors as a way to avoid that emotion and dissociate. They binge on a certain type of food and then purging to get rid of that guilt after that experience.
Now there are other eating disorders as well. Another one in the diagnostic material is binge eating disorder, which is the overconsumption of food. Again, that overconsumption of the food is a way to avoid those uncomfortable emotions. You know, it's a way to just numb ourselves out. Now, binge eating disorder does not have the same behaviors afterwards to compensate for the binge. So we don't see the same purging that we'll see with bulimia nervosa. And that's kind of how we distinguish those two.
Additionally, there is avoidant restrictive food intake disorder, also known as ARFID. This is a newer diagnosis that is still being researched, and so we're working out the pieces of it. But ARFID is really characterized by avoidance of food or either taste or texture reasons or fear based experiential reason, maybe a fear of choking on something, but it leads to really limited food choices. There'll be maybe five things that somebody will eat. And we see this a lot in people with also a diagnosis of some sort of neurodiversity. If they've got kind of high sensitivity to different sensations that can kind of lend itself towards that.
Amanda Giordano: How do these eating disorders typically develop and what are the risk factors that might increase a teen's susceptibility or vulnerability to an eating disorder?
Erin Birely: Yeah, so eating disorders develop out of a perfect storm kind of experience. There's no one cause there's not one thing that we can say to parents like, “Just make sure they don't do this, and they'll be fine.”
So we talk about them developing out of a biopsychosocial model or the idea that there are biological risk factors. So genetic risk factors, whether that's a genetic predisposition to anxiety. So people in the past having anxiety, OCD, a diagnosed eating disorder, all of these can be risk factors.
We're also looking at some biological risk factors in terms of set point weight. So where does somebody whose body naturally like to hang out and how does that compare to the societal ideals of what a body, quote unquote, should look like? So that can be another piece.
Also, metabolic differences that happen. So how quickly or not quickly people lose weight, gain weight. Development around puberty can be another biologic aspect that can impact. So there's a lot of different pieces.
And then psychologically, we also look at, you know, just personality type. One of the things we know, people who are more perfectionistic have more of that perfectionistic personality type are a little bit more likely to maybe fall into some of those eating disorder mindsets because their brains are already set up to be kind of all or nothing.
And I always like to remind people, perfectionism has two sides. There's the perfectionist we all think of like everything is perfect, everything is great. But then there's that flip side of perfectionism that’s “Well, I know I can't do it perfectly. So I'm not even going to try.” And we don't often think about that being the perfectionist. It's still on that perfectionism side, though. It's just that flip side of it.
And then we also know that social environments and just society as a whole has an impact. So seeing other people put weight as a determinant of their self-worth, seeing other people be excluded because of body size or the way they walk or how they eat or what they eat, those can all be pieces that play a role.
Additionally, also, what's the culture around emotions for this person? Are they living in a world where it's, you know, let yourself feel your emotions, let yourself tolerate them, or is that pull yourself up by your bootstraps and just get through and do it? All of that's going to impact.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. And I think that biopsychosocial model is such a great framework for understanding there's not one cause. And then I would imagine that means there's not one silver bullet cure either.
Erin Birely: No. And at the same time, you know, I encourage parents, you know, think about what's their relationship like with their body? How do they talk about food at home? Like think about the workplace. Think about the number of times you hear somebody say, “No, I can't have that. I'm trying to be good today.” Or like, “Oh, I was so bad over the weekend, I need to have a salad.” Like we put this morality on food. It's so commonplace, and we don't even think about it, and we don't even think about what that then is telling us and telling the people around us.
Because what that says is that, okay, so then whether I'm a good or bad person depends somewhat on what I'm eating. And it's like, well, that doesn't seem right. I always encourage parents to think about how do they talk about food. Is there a moral piece around food?
Amanda Giordano: What does treatment entail if a adolescent does have one of eating disorders that you mentioned, what does treatment look like?
Erin Birely: You know, treatment can look different based off of the needs of the kid and also of the family. One of the big things you'll hear, especially for adolescents, young adolescents, is FBT or the Maudsley Method. So it's family-based treatment and that can be a really effective treatment model. It really puts the responsibility on the parents. It focuses on them increasing control around the food. They're really doing everything for the kid and then slowly the kid gets their control back. They get as they progress, they get that back. That can be super effective.
And at the same time, I also know some parents, who are like, “We both work full time, and we have two other kids. Can't put all of this on me.” And I'm like, I get that. And so in those instances it might look a little bit different. It might look like, you know, doing a multidisciplinary outpatient team, it might look like a higher level of care treatment where the kids are taken out of that home environment so they can get the support that they need to stop those behaviors, really cut out the behavioral reinforcement piece and then the family can work on, OK, so what do we need to do to support them to continue this?
Amanda Giordano: Are there any warning signs that parents should be aware of when it comes to the development of an eating disorder?
Erin Birely: You know, it's tough because there are warning signs that also look like just normal teenage behavior in our society. But I think for parents, it's really looking at, you know, if there's a big shift in your kid's relationship with food, if you notice that all of a sudden things that they used to really enjoy, they're saying, I can't.
Especially when it then also has to do with the social aspect. You know, you think about kids going out, grabbing ice cream together, some like very normal summer activity. Like when you notice your kid's not doing that anymore. They're missing out on those social aspects to follow kind of food rules. If you notice that they're really withdrawing both from you and they're friends, that social withdrawal. It’s really hard to maintain relationships and be really focused on your eating disorder.
And then emotional only as well. If you're noticing that lower intensity of emotions, they just seem a little bit flatter. We're not really seeing that emotional breadth. And when we are seeing it, it's a real high intensity and we're not sure where it's coming from. Those are some good warning signs. Just be on the lookout for.
Amanda Giordano: And you mentioned with treatment the different types of treatment that there are a lot of behavioral interventions that have to do with food. I wonder if treatment also has that emotional component, if emotional avoidance is behind a lot of these behaviors, is that part of the work that would be done with an adolescent?
Erin Birely: Yeah. So at Renfrew Centers and anyone that now has access to our Renfrew for Center Unified Treatment Model Workbook for outpatient providers, the work really is that behavioral change. And then how do we lean in and start to feel the emotions that come up around that behavior change?
So thinking more about how do you not only stop the behavior, but then let yourself feel that emotion and build up your belief in your ability to tolerate that emotion. Because that's really, I mean, you think about just normal development.
That's why things feel like such a big deal when we're teens, because it's our first time. And so we're building up our belief in our ability over time. It's the same thing that we're doing in treatment. We're slowly working on tolerating more and more intense emotions, and we encourage the family to do the same.
You know, that's something we work on with parents as well, because it's hard for parents to see their kids hurt and upset. And a parent's natural inclination is to make them feel better. You know, that's been your job and all of a sudden we're sitting there and we're going through treatment. We're saying, “Okay, I want you to be okay with the fact that they're not going to be okay.” So it's the parents doing that work, too.
Amanda Giordano: Yeah. So really bringing in the whole family unit into this treatment.
Great. And so just in closing, I'm curious, and what do you want parents or caregivers and professionals who work with youth to know about eating disorders?
Erin Birely: I think I want them to know that it's about so much more than the food. It's so much more than the food and the body. And it's really about the emotions. And if we get stuck on just focusing on the food and the body image components, we miss out on those deeper things, those deeper aspects that are going to keep showing up.
So remembering that, like there's the whole world going on underneath the food and the body image piece and that's what's really important. And we have to get there by changing the behaviors first.
Amanda Giordano: Great. Erin, thank you so much for being with us today and for this wisdom that you shared. And for our listeners, thank you so much for joining us on the Safety First podcast, where we tackle tough topics that affect today's teens. I'm your host, Amanda Giordano, and we hope you'll join us for our next episode.